Day 132 – Hotel Forrest Lake

Hotel Forrest Lake Sanford FL

Have you ever driven by this building right on West Seminole Boulevard and wondered what exactly it is? Well, today I can tell you what exactly it was…

“Known by local residents as the “Mayfair”, this three-story Mediterranean Revival hotel was built in 1925, It was named after Forrest Lake, at the time the mayor of the City of Sanford, who commissioned its construction for one-half million dollars.

The 158-room hotel was designed by Sanford architect Elton J. Moughton. It was part of the waterfront beautification plan that included construction of the bulkhead and Seminole Boulevard. Additionally, East First Street had to be extended from its terminus at Sanford Avenue to reach the new hotel in 1925.

In 1928 the Hotel Forrest Lake closed as a result of an investment scandal involving Mayor Lake and a local bank. In 1930 the hotel was purchased by the City of Sanford and renamed the Mayfair Hotel. In the following years it changed hands several times. It was owned by the Kirchoff family and then by the U.S. Navy.

In 1948 the hotel was purchased by the New York Giants Major League Baseball team. The team changed the name of the hotel to the Mayfair Inn. The Giants’ farm teams held spring training in Sanford during the late 1940s and early 1950s.

From 1963 to 1977 the hotel served as the Sanford Naval Academy, a private military school for boys. During this period the interior of the building was extensively altered and all the remaining historic furnishings were sold off.

In 1978 the New Tribes Mission, a non-denominational international missionary group, purchased the hotel and converted it into the organization’s headquarters. Many of the hotel’s guest rooms were converted into apartments for missionaries.”

I quoted this text off the Historical Marker Database, a really cool web site that lists the texts of thousands of historical markers. Very nice because I was ready to type it all up myself (I took a picture of the text on the marker when I was there today…).

As mentioned in the text, today the former hotel is New Tribes Mission’s headquarter. I am planning on visiting them soon…

1000 E. First Street – Sanford, FL 32771

About The Author


Hi, my name is Claudia! I live, work and play in Sanford, FL. To top it all off, I am also totally in love with Sanford! My husband Jose and I are Realtors in Sanford, FL and help people realize their dreams of home ownership. We have two sons, Nicolas (2011) and Lukas (2013). I am originally from Germany, moved here in 2004. In 2008 I started I love everything that says creativity. Design is my passion, no matter if Graphic, Web or Fashion Design - and I am also into photography :) I'm also very social and love to hang out with my family and friends, be it for a kids play date or a fun night out ;)

Leave a reply


Subscribe to our Channel

Featured Home

Price Change - 4 weeks ago
349 Meadow Beauty Terrace Sanford, FL 32771
Single Family Home For Sale
- Active

Dream Home Alert! This 4,000+ square feet 5 bedroom pool home is situated on a 1/3 acre lot in desirable Berington Club. As a resident of this gated community you get to enjoy easy access to the Seminole Trail as well as top restaurants and shopping.

Read the latest issue of our partner My Sanford Magazine

FREE Email Report!

Never Miss a Thing in Sanford

Join our mailing list to receive our free weekly event preview and news digest. No spam. Ever. Promised! 

Thank you! Just one more step: check your email account now and find the email we just sent you. Click the link inside to activate your subscription!