Day 264 – Papa Joe’s Pizza in Lake Mary FL

Day 264 – Papa Joe’s Pizza in Lake Mary FL

Papa Joe's PizzaIf you’re feeling like having a quick pizza or craving some pasta, Papa Joe’s is a good place to go. I personally think that it’s worth paying a bit more elsewhere when you want to eat Italian food but I think the Pizza here is pretty decent and, like I said, it’s not a place to spend an evening – it’s the quick occasional pizza, as in “pizza after a movie” or “pizza because it rains outside”… This particular location can be found right next to the Amstar Movie theatre in Lake Mary’s Colonial Town Park.

Here’s their info:

Papa Joe’s Pizza
960 Colonial Grand Ln
Lake Mary, FL 32746-4778
(407) 936-3300?

About The Author


Hi, my name is Claudia! I live, work and play in Sanford, FL. To top it all off, I am also totally in love with Sanford! My husband Jose and I are Realtors in Sanford, FL and help people realize their dreams of home ownership. We have two sons, Nicolas (2011) and Lukas (2013). I am originally from Germany, moved here in 2004. In 2008 I started I love everything that says creativity. Design is my passion, no matter if Graphic, Web or Fashion Design - and I am also into photography :) I'm also very social and love to hang out with my family and friends, be it for a kids play date or a fun night out ;)


  1. Mays43

    Beware of Papa Joe’s pizza in Lake Mary, Florida. Not recommended. We ordered delivery pizza, paid for 3 toppings, received only 2 and those were skimpy at best. My wife called to complain and was insulted by the Manager, who told her to “go F*ck yourself with (another) pizza business”. Refused to refund the money. We placed complaint with the Better Business Bureau. We are Lake Mary residents and we have never been mistreated by any other business in this manner.

  2. Sherry

    I think its great what you have done here. You have mapped out a lot of different places for my husband and I to visit. Papa Joes is one of our favorites. There cheesecake is homemade and to die for. Even though my body gets mad at me for it. I frequent both pllaces papa joes has in Lake Mary. The store next to the movie theatre does get a little noisy when they are filled up, so we just go to the other one, if thats the case.

  3. Lisa Barrows

    I had food catered in for a group meeting. The catering part was fine until we realized that they did not have a detailed receipt. They treated me horribly when I asked for one with complete attitude from the get go. Sent me a receipt and the pricing was wrong and didn’t match the credit card receipt. Kept telling me I was bothering them and wasting their time in essence for making them go back and correct a receipt. When they sent it to me it was wrong and asked me to recreate what we ate a month later. I do a lot of these events and can’t remember everything I order at every place. Their last comment is they are annoyed because they have been dealing with me all day on this. Like I want to deal with a receipt issue all day. I am trying to prevent someone from getting fired because their receipts don’t match up. Completely unprofessional and the two managers I spoke to basically had the whole staff treat me with an attitude over the situation. They don’t seem to care because they are family owned and there is no corporate office to complain to. I do a hundred of these a year in various locations and have never been treated so poorly and rudely and with so much attitude.

Leave a reply


FREE Email Report!

Read the latest issue of My Sanford Magazine

Never Miss a Thing in Sanford

Join our mailing list to receive our free weekly event preview and news digest. No spam. Ever. Promised! 

Thank you! Just one more step: check your email account now and find the email we just sent you. Click the link inside to activate your subscription!